Tag: User Experience

  • From T-shaped to π-shaped designer

    The role of designers is changing and new approaches are needed to foster a mindset that can support them to become more impact-focused and a key strategic partner. How can DesignOps help driving Designers’ transformation to maximise results and influence?

    A T-Shaped designer had great skills and a focus on execution and delivery. But a π-shaped designer i data driven and focused on impact and collaborative conversations that can drive maximum results.

    Design has gone a long way in the past 10 years thanks to the rise and impact of Design Thinking and to the impact design has had on businesses. There are a number of studies reporting how companies with Design teams have higher profits, such as McKinsey 2018, John Maeda’s Design in Tech Reports, The Forrester Report 2020.

    Yet, many design leaders still complain about the role and positioning of Design within their organisation, claiming that their team is unable to influence conversations and that Design is still expected to execute briefs and deliver pixel-perfect prototypes or designs. But that is only one side of the story, because it is also important to learn what is the experience that engineers, product managers, and marketing teams are having with the design teams to answer the question Are design teams really misunderstood or are they missing an opportunity?

    To answer this question, both the shape of the design teams and designers’ skills matter and influence the positioning of Design.

    We have seen a growth in the so-called T-shaped designers: technically impeccable designers capable of perfectly execute any brief and delivering on time. These are greatly talented and highly skilled professionals, but to fully empower Design to reach the strategic positioning it deserves, they need to learn to collaborate on new grounds and with enhanced approaches with their cross-functional partners to ensure designers are not executing briefs but influencing decisions.

    It is DesignOps’ role to own this issue and to define the strategic approach to understand the root causes of this situation. And this required a deep understanding of what was the current experience that design partners were having with designers. A survey and 1:1 interviews revealed that there were a certain number of recurrent issues that cross-functional partners were experiencing with the design teams, but two were the key issues that were having the biggest impact: designers’ limited decision-making capacity and the design team’s overall reactive attitude.

    Why that? Why these aspects were important and where were these issues coming from?

    From Design Thinking to Data thinking

    Design Thinking has made empathy and user obsession one of the signatures of how design teams operate. Yet Design Thinking’s overall qualitative approach that investigates unmet needs has not been fully expanded towards a stronger formalised data-driven quantitative approach to measure users behaviours and impact.

    In the era of the quantified self, it’s also time to start thinking and embracing the era of the quantified user, and to do so designers need to evolve their approach to new dimensions.

    If Design is about nudging users to adopt better ways to achieve their goals, if it is about creating delight and meaningful experiences, measuring behaviours and quantifying the impact of the experiences that are being delivered is the single most important element to ensure design thinking has the impact it promises in its empathy-led approach. This becomes important because if cross-functional partners are using metrics and KPIs to assess performance and impact, it is hard for designers to compete on the same level when they focus mostly on stories and empathy with no solid data-driven approaches.

    Empathy and narratives are essential to influence, but decisions today are made with data.

    T-shaped designers in our teams were not fully relying on analytics: when in an internal survey and follow up interviews designers were asked about the tools and data points they were using to make decisions, the vast majority admitted not only that they felt they did not know much about analytics, but they were not sure about the tools and resources that were available to them. 
    And although the organisation had 3+ analytics tools available to all in an effort to democratise data, yet many designers felt that analytics was “the analytics guys’ stuff”.

    But having to rely on the analytics’ guys to get behavioural data, also meant that when a designer wanted to check on the performance of an in product feature, these queries had very low priority for the analytics teams, meaning that the data may take days or even weeks to arrive. And of course, these low added value asks from the design teams were not helping the relationship between Design and Analytics.

    This demonstrates the need to rethink designers’ mindset and move from a T-shaped to a π-shaped approach to Design. π-shaped designers combine Design Thinking with a solid data driven approach: they use data to make informed decision and to quantify changes in users’ behaviours. π-shaped designers drive conversations and visions with their cross-functional partners thanks to the shared focus on impact and the ability to use analytics as a common language: in this new approach, data complements and strengthens designers’ deep understanding of the users’ pain-points and supports their capacity to be part of the decisions and to be proactive in identifying impactful opportunities.

    What if we nurture a data-informed mindset?

    These considerations led to an experiment: can we foster, and measure designers’ mindset?

    This type of overarching strategic initiatives fall within DesignOps’ strategic remit. Fostering a data driven mentality, requires an ongoing commitment, time, and support from the leadership and the teams and it needs a combination of both the technical training on existing platforms and ongoing exposure to best practices and case studies.

    DesignOps partnered with the analytics platform suppliers by sharing the concerns, analysing the expertise gaps, discussing the opportunities, and defining a learning plan to increase teams’ understanding of the platforms.
    On the other side, a number of Subject Matter Experts have been invited to share case studies, best practices, examples on how analytics and data can be used in Design and innovation.

    This soon become a 6 months’ initiative: both the technical training on tools and mindset shaping initiatives were needed to ensure designers started asking the right questions and touse tools to answer those questions. 
    Data driven is a mindset that is supported by tools and platforms. The agreed commitment with design leaders and teams was to attend 90 minutes’ sessions 3 times a month. Basically a total of 4.5 hours a month with a weekly commitment.

    The results after 6 months

    Assessing the impact of how training initiative impact teams’ development of a more data informed mindset requires… data!

    For this reason, ahead of the sessions, all designers were asked to fill a skill matrix assessment to understand teams’ strengths and opportunities and to assess the level of confidence in data and in analytics platforms and tools. We also collected analytics data to understand the current engagement and utilisation of the existing data platforms to answer a key question: how much and how often were designers engaging with analytics tools?

    It was important to both understand self-perception and to triangulate that with behaviours to get a full picture of the initial situation and to quantify actions and attitudes.

    All these data point, the behavioural analytics and the skill matrix, were the baseline. 6 months and 30 hours trainings later, designers were asked to fill the same matrix and new data were collected from the platforms to understand if there were any changes in designers’ behaviours.

    Yes, the needle was moving and it was moving in the right direction!

    Designers were asked to rate their confidence in the domains touched by the trainings, and while confidence in data and analytics increased up to 12% with an average increase of 8%, the confidence in using analytics tools and platforms increased by up to 29%!

    Behavioural data from platforms’ analytics confirmed these self-assessments, with an increased engagement that overcome all initial hypothesis: in 6 months there was a 70% uplift in the number of data and analytics projects launched by designers, an 1,800% increase in designers’ queries to the platforms, and a +170% increase in overall engagement with all analytics tools.

    Can we foster and nurture a data-driven mindset?

    Yes, we can. But it takes time: these results are just a starting point: maintaining momentum, ensuring new acquired behaviours become habits, strengthening confidence, and establishing the habit to think and to make decision with data is a mindset that needs to be exercised constantly, like a muscle.

    These initial results can be quickly nullified by the wrong initiatives and it is now key to rethink and to learn from these 6 months to identify opportunities to consolidate the learnings and nurture the mindset.

    Because one positive result is not a victory, it is the beginning of more targeted and efficient actions to increase designers’ engagement and excitement for data and to ensure we foster the π-shaped mentality that can allow Design to move into the strategic and influencing space it deserves.

    The UX Collective donates US$1 for each article published on our platform. This story contributed to Bay Area Black Designers: a professional development community for Black people who are digital designers and researchers in the San Francisco Bay Area. By joining together in community, members share inspiration, connection, peer mentorship, professional development, resources, feedback, support, and resilience. Silence against systemic racism is not an option. Build the design community you believe in.
  • UX is strategy in action

    The UX practices and mindsets are evolving. It’s becoming clear that UX is not just about user validation, pixels, or wireframes. That’s the old paradigm. UX is much more. UX permeates the whole design process and the overall underlying strategy. Because UX is strategy in action.

    A little bit of history: do you remember when…?

    For many years UX has been dominated by the design/wireframe and testing paradigm, and this is not a surprise.

    Although stemming from HCI and UCD, the real turning point in the dissemination of a user centred culture was early 2000, when Jakob Nielsen and Donald Norman have highlighted and explained the importance of usability and good design.

    The initial reaction of the industry was to introduce user testing, heuristics, and guidelines to support designers developing products that were accessible, usable, and fairly simple. The delight and the pleasure of using the digital products were still not fully understood, as at that time, the main focus was onfunctionalities and delivering products that offered new digitalised services — e-banking, e-commerce, e-learning… Usability was the magic word, as all those new services needed to be sufficiently easy to use to attract early adopters.

    The competition was somehow limited, and the new services served the purpose to offer something new, innovative, answering an emergent need or exploiting a new opportunity. User testing was the perfect answer: asking the user to validate the concepts and UI was seen as a key step to make sure products and services were reasonably usable.

    But soon the emergent needs became habits, and the reasonable usable concepts became inadequate for the growing market. Technology also evolved fast — someone may still remember WAP sites on incredibly slow Edge phones, when accessing the site was already perceived as achievement.

    Now we live the times of the Always-on, and we can hardly imagine our lives without being constantly connected. And this caused the competition for the user to change quickly: more and more providers started offering similar and competing services on the new emerging digital platforms, and the user needs could be fulfilled by countless different offers from different providers.

    Answering users’ needs or exploiting a market opportunity soon was not enough anymore, and user testings and heuristics, despite remaining great tools, were not adequate to keep up with a fast paced competition to grab users’ attention, time, and loyalty.

    This is the same time when the experience economy paradigm was emerging, highlighting how users were not looking for services, but experiences: the shift from a service based economy, to an experience based economy has been subtle but key in determining how the UX industry evolved. And this new paradigm meant that good UI and IxD design and user validation and testing were not sufficient anymore, that a new way of engaging with the user and a new way of thinking and designing was needed.

    And then UX appeared: the user as the sole expert in their experiences, where designers, researchers, developers, and strategists operate together to understand the opportunities and develop complex experiences, rather than products. The new opportunities today are not meant to fill a need, but to satisfy the desire to feel engaged and delighted by the interaction with a service or product that is perceived by the user as valuable and meaningful.

    …And this is where we are…

    The UX industry is maturing and it is becoming clear that UX is an end-to-end process that ends with design and the delivery of products and services through iterative user testing phases, but it starts with explorative and generative research to define the strategy and what is valuable and meaningful for the users.

    The wider adoption of ethnography based methods and the increased attention to users mental models, behaviours, attitudes, and emotions before the design phase kicks off indicates that the UX practice is moving towards a more holistic and strategic dimension, embracing and including the user at its very core to deliver and generate value.

    Because it’s not anymore about the pure function, as in the old usability and user testing days, but it’s about the experience. It’s not about the what can be done, but it’s all about the how it feels.

    Strategists, researchers, designers, and developers are the professionals that can and should translate users’ mental models and expectations into experiences that empower the users and the brand, but the sole experts in their experience are always and only the users.

    UX is a strategic holistic approach, where the service or product is strategy in action. In a mature UX process, execution and design complement and embody the understanding of what users think, feel, expect, like, and value to generate value, meaning, and relationships.

  • UX Lessons from E.T.

    As UX professionals, we tend to consider our users as our key focus: we engage in research activities, try to understand their explicit and implicit needs, imagine how would they behave, interact, and react to our services and designs.

    I could not think of any personification of the perfect UX professional, until today. It’s Elliot, do you remember the kid in E.T. who befriends the strange extraterrestrial creature?

    Elliot’s attitude towards E.T. is a perfect Ux attitude of openness, lack of prejudice, genuine curiosity towards the users and their goals, absence of any agenda. Elliot engages so much with E.T. that at the end Elliot becomes E.T.’s toolto communicate and share its feeling with the world.

    At the end of the movie, when a scientist tries to understand the relationship between Elliot and E.T., Michael [Elliot’s brother] explains the special connection Elliot and E.T. have established:

    Michael: He [E.T.]’s smart. He communicates through Elliott.

    Scientist: Elliott thinks its thoughts.

    Michael: No, Elliott… Elliott feels his feelings.

    This is exactly what UXers should do: feel the users feelings and avoid thinking instead or in lieu of the user.

    E.T. from a UX point of view, is nothing more than a user: someone who has a goal in mind: he wants phone home. Elliot is his consultant and guide on planet Earth, helping him to interact in this dimension and to find the way to accomplish his goal.

    And Elliot succeed because he genuinely cares for E.T., because he thinks out of the box, because he finds like-minded people to help, because he does not apply old or established processes.

    When E.T. is captured by the scientists and MDs have to decide how to save E.T.’s life, they do not question who the patient is and they mechanically apply on E.T. all their sterile, tested, and approved protocols: procedures and practices that may work for human being, but they did not considered that E.T. is clearly not a human being.

    E.T. is saved and is able to go home because Elliot joins efforts with like minded people. In a great team effort, a bunch of teenagers saves E.T. and let him to gohome.

    When dealing with Users we should be more like Elliot: explore the new user, be their unbiased, sincere guide in the digital dimension, understand and put efforts and genuine curiosity in understanding who the users are, what are their goals, how do they feel, and avoid thinking instead of them — we should use our empathy to feel more like them and avoid protocols. The answer is just in being more Elliot.