Tag: Management

  • Understanding DesignOps as a strategic function — PART 2

    PART 2

    Part 2 of 2

    DesignOps relies on ongoing performance assessments to constantly evaluate what can be done better to impact positively the business metrics. Yes, DesignOps’ impact is quantifiable.

    Post-its with key words, such as finance, work, create.
    Credits: https://www.pexels.com/@nietjuh

    The application of a system thinking business mindset relies on DesignOps leaders ability to apply a solid analytical approach to quantify impact and inefficiencies and to focus on aspects that can bring more value to the organisation as a whole.

    To do so DesignOps has a very specific set of KPIs, that are unique to its domain and which complement the Chief Design Officer’s performance indicators.

    Design Leaders assesses the value of Design through metrics that take into account outward-looking variables, such as product and marketing dimensions. The metrics that the Design leader will consider typically include funnel related metrics, conversion and retention rates, CSAT, PRS, NPS, CES, and other engagement metrics.

    On the other hand, the DesignOps leader defines internal inward looking metrics focusing on the teams’ performances and behaviours. To do so, DesignOps focuses on operational dimensions to assess what impact are the design teams creating through the ways of working and the design process and execution.

    DesignOps metrics are defined by two main types of indicators: Operational Efficiency and Operational Efficacy.

    Operational Efficiency are metrics related to the ways processes are streamlined and bottlenecks have been removed, and they include KPIs such as:

    • Tools’ engagement and utilisation metrics
    • Rapid testing and prototyping lead time
    • Number and type of quality reviews
    • Team productivity
    • Delivery time
    • Cost and budget ROI

    Operational Efficiency focuses on how resources — time, money, people — are utilised and it defines the opportunities to maximise the organisations’ return of investment.

    Operational Efficacy focuses on soft metrics that assess inner qualities of the teams and the execution of a design thinking approach. These type of KPIs measures and weights behaviours that have a direct impact on operational efficiencies such as:

    • Empathy and the capacity to deliver on an ongoing user-centred engagement
    • Ideation and experimentation cycle times
    • Composition of teams’ skills and skills’ distribution
    • Perceived value of design teams by cross-functional partners
    • Employee satisfaction and retention

    Both Efficiency and Efficacy metrics deliver and impact spending and operational targets and these indicators are key to drive C-level conversation between DesignOps, Design, and cross functional partners to identify collaboration and operational opportunities. By applying a system thinking approach to the design operation, DesignOps delivers value and a strategic direction to maximise the impact of design thinking.

    How to apply Efficiency and Efficacy metrics to maximise business performances

    While internal inefficiencies are endemic in many organisations, inefficiencies in design can have a business impact that can erode the value and benefits that design brings to the business and have costly consequences for the organisation. This is why setting clear metrics that help understanding how design teams operate, how budget are spent, how teams are developed, becomes a strategic function to maximise efficiencies and the value of design. But how is DesignOps generating benefits and value?

    Increasing efficiency by understanding teams’ time utilisation

    When assessing inefficiencies it is important not only to understand what are the biggest operational issues, but to also understand how much those inefficiencies compromise the organisations’ operating values and how much inefficiencies impact culture and results.

    This is why when I looked to increase the efficiency and workflows of 60 designers distributed in 7 teams across the globe, I took into account not only the internal impact, but also the impact of those inefficiencies on the company’s values, because organisational values determine and influence behaviours.
    Therefore in design driven companies, design teams are expected to constantly engage and learn from users through research and rapid experiments.

    In 2018 the international teams I was managing, were facing a rapid growth and operational inefficiencies were causing long hours and impacting the overall workflow and production cycle. The design teams were struggling in sourcing research participants. 
     From an analysis I run, it emerged that on average a designer spent between 2 to 2.5 days to source, contact, schedule, and reward the 5/6 participants needed for every session. With 2 weeks’ sprints, it meant that designers were spending up to 5 working days a month sourcing participants. This revealed additional inefficiencies:

    • Designers were working long hours to make up for the time spend in non-design tasks, impacting designers’ life/work balance
    • In some markets, the cost to recruit participants could be as high as $360/participant due to agency overheads
    • The lead time was between 2.5 to 4 weeks
    • The need for speed caused the widespread of poor practices

    To solve for this problem, as DesignOps we implemented an internal participant sourcing service: this service would then act as an internal agency so that designers could efficiently outsource the recruitment needs of their job to a dedicated team. After a 12 months’ proof of concept, it has taken 10 months to roll out the service in all markets with a clear impact on operational and spending metrics:

    • The lead time decreased by 65%
    • The number of users involved in testing increased by 4 times
    • The spending for recruitment was reduced on average by 60%
    • The design teams saved 430 working days, equivalent to 2 FTEs, with a forecast to double this number for the second year.

    Increasing efficiencies through analytics and data

    One of the most common spending inefficiencies in design teams is represented by tools: organisations invest significant budget in different resources, often with no clear idea about the impact of these new tools for the end-to-end design process. Moreover, the relationship with vendors and suppliers is often transactional: design leaders have no time to focus on creating a mutually beneficial relationship and to define a tool rollout and implementation strategy with their third party suppliers.
     So, it is not uncommon that tools are rolled out with limited support and unclear expectations. And once the tool is implemented, the renewal is often automatic with no in depth analysis of analytics, engagement and utilisation metrics to assess the cost/benefit impact of the investment.

    It is then cleat that crossing data points, such as tools’ analytics, designers’ feedback, and by engaging with third party vendors is essential to determine the right strategy to optimise investments and improve operations. And this is exactly where DesignOps acts.

    An in-depth analysis of engagement and utilisation of tools in use in 2019, has produced significant impact on both the business and the operations, such as:

    • reducing by 60% the cost on unmoderated user testing platforms that were serving only English speaking markets by introducing new platforms that serve all 7 markets
    • Saving over 85% on cross-functional tools by assessing active licenses and utilisation to renegotiate the contracts
    • Identify tools with low engagement and collaborate with vendors and teams to create ad hoc trainings to embed the new tools in the existing workflows

    These results show how a deep understanding of the operation is key for efficiencies and to empower teams: but this level of efficiency can only be achieved through a strategic lens that looks at the business impact of design decisions to maximise ROI. And this is where Design and DesignOps leader partner to define the most effective and efficient operational models for their teams and their organisation.

    What’s next

    By linking Design with business and by focusing on bringing tangible benefits, organisations looking to maximise their investment in Design should start looking at DesignOps as a new strategic function working alongside the Design and the organisation’s leaders to reveal the inefficiencies that compromise growth and profit.

    Especially organisations that have large, distributed, or fast growing and expanding design teams can gain the biggest benefits from the introduction of DesignOps.

    The examples demonstrate DesignOps’ strategic function in connecting creative and user centred design processes with the need to create business value through optimised execution and streamlined processes.

    This is because of all functions within the organisations, DesignOps is the critical enabler for organisational ambidexterity.
     With its focus on processes, resources, teams, budget, and operational metrics, DesignOps delivers a major impact on the exploitative functions: the in depth analysis and understanding of all issues that undermine design teams’ capacity to deliver routine tasks is a critical mean that empowers design leaders to invest more on explorative opportunities.

    In the example mentioned earlier, the 430 working days that were gained through the introduction of new processes, can be re-invested by design teams in explorative initiatives, with each team gaining on average 60 working days. This creates additional value and can impact business performance and innovation capacity.

    By reducing the need to focus on operations, design leaders can concentrate on the execution and definition of the design and innovation strategy, knowing that all operational aspects are being taken care.

    And by increasing operational efficiencies and streamlining the end-to-end processes, DesignOps creates the conditions for ambidexterity and higher impact both on the organisations’ ability to deliver innovation and the teams’ capacity to grow and expand.

    Few functions have the same capacity to impact organisations at the same level and to support both innovation, customer driven innovation, business performances, and efficiencies as DesignOps.

    But this can only be achieved if DesignOps is positioned as a strategic role within the organisation, with a clear remit and vision, and with the support to execute the strategy.

    The UX Collective donates US$1 for each article published on our platform. This story contributed to Bay Area Black Designers: a professional development community for Black people who are digital designers and researchers in the San Francisco Bay Area. By joining together in community, members share inspiration, connection, peer mentorship, professional development, resources, feedback, support, and resilience. Silence against systemic racism is not an option. Build the design community you believe in.
  • Understanding DesignOps as a Strategic Function

    What is DesignOps and at which altitude should it be positioned to maximize impact? — Part 1 of 2

    Credits: https://www.pexels.com/@lanophotography

    What is DesignOps and where does it come from?

    Design has become a central function in most businesses: in the past 10 years, due to the emergence of design thinking and its impact on business performance, many organisations invested in design and have embedded design in the production cycle (McKinsey 2015).

    This new positioning of Design has led many organisations to acquire or invest in Design teams, and over time, these design units have become organisations within the organisation.

    As Design teams grow within organisations, both in terms of teams’ size and number of teams, the need of harmonising design workflows and coordinating efforts and processes has led to the demand for new competencies to help the organisation to manage the complexity of their Design resources.

    Despite the lack of a unified definition of who or what is needed to support organisations in maximising their investment in design, a growing number of companies are introducing a new function focused on increasing Design’s impact on business performance through improved Design’s operation: DesignOps.

    DesignOps is an internal focused function that applies a system thinking approach to understand how Design teams operate inside-out and outside-in to identify opportunities and create business benefits through improved spending and operational performances.

    Through the collaboration with both design and cross-functional leaders, DesignOps generates value through the understanding of design’s end-to-end processes and the definition of effective engagement models that support the execution and implementation of the Design strategy.

    DesignOps delivers impact by concentrating on Design teams as their unit of work and it focuses on creating the conditions to empower design teams to collaborate with the cross-functional partners.

    By overseeing the day-to-day and the end-to-end design process across the organisation, the DesignOps leader focuses on streamlining processes, building and maintaining a design community, harmonising ways of working across design and cross-functional teams while overseeing key operational aspects such as the budget, tools, and the relationship with external partners.

    In short, DesignOps analyses the teams’ workflows and the organisation’s needs to identify opportunities to maximise Design’s impact on business performances.

    In the past few months, the need to improve and redefine ways of working due the pandemic has suddenly amplified the hype on DesignOps, especially after some organisations have reported how DesignOps minimised disruption and made the transition to a Work from Home model efficient and seamless.

    This has caused a rapid increase in the demand for DesignOps professionals and leaders, yet the lack of clear tasks, expectations, and responsibilities, and an unclear positioning of these new figures is causing confusion and it is preventing DesignOps from delivering benefits and impact. Two are the main source of confusion: the altitude of the role, and the relationship between Design and DesignOps.

    DesignOps and Design Programme Managers

    The first issue with the introduction of DesignOps is related to its focus and altitude: following the new trend, some organisations have re-branded their design producers and project managers as DesignOps Managers or they simply considered DesignOps to be the same as the Design Programme Manager, or DPM. These roles are very different in their remit and responsibilities: DPMs and DesignOps work together, but they operate at different levels and failing to understand this could generate additional inefficiencies.

    This is because while DesignOps operates at a strategic level, the Design Programme Manager, as the name suggest, operate at a tactical one and the skills and competencies for the two roles are different.

    DesignOps defines a vision, KPIs, and result-driven roadmaps that focus on design processes through a business lens, while Design Programme Management works on the execution of the roadmap to ensure the vision is delivered and the expected impact is achieved. 
     
     Design Programme Managers’ typical tasks include facilitation and logistics, tools’ administration, project management and tracking, and coordination of trainings and workshops. A DPM executes decisions: DPMs operate at a tactical level and they are generally aligned to a specific squad or scrum team, meaning that DPMs are expected to be familiar with the product development.

    DesignOps leaders are strategic decision makers, they set a data informed vision for the Design operation, they define the tools’ ecosystem, they negotiate contracts and manage suppliers, they identify ways to grow the teams, they make engagement plans to increase cross-functional and cross-market collaboration, and they are accountable to identify gaps and opportunities to maximise spending returns.

    A DesignOps leader acts at a business strategy level by connecting and engaging with cross functional and cross market C-level leaders to streamline design practices across the whole organisation.

    Failing to recognise DesignOps’ function as a strategic executive functions and implementing only DPMs without an overarching strategy that leads to systematic and ongoing operational improvements is one of the most common misinterpretation of the role. It is indeed important to understand that designOps leaders are in fact designers who speak the business language who apply a business and analytical mindset to the creative process of design to amplify the impact of design on business performances. Design Programme Managers are the executive arm that ensures efficiencies are achieved on the ground.

    DesignOps and Design leaders: complementary to maximise business performance

    The second area of confusion is DesignOps’ relationship with Design leaders.
     One of the biggest challenges when introducing a DesignOps leader in an organisation is the definition of their role and responsibilities with the existing Design Leaders, who may feel confused or even threatened by the new function.

    DesignOps complements and expands Design leaders’ ability to maximise impact, and in fact DesignOps does not reduce Design leaders’ sphere of influence, but together they amplify Design’s impact and benefits for the whole organisation. For this reason it is essential that DesignOps and Design leaders partner to ensure the operational and design strategy are aligned and optimised.
     As a simplification, we can say that the relationship between the design leader, or Chef Design Officer (CDO) and DesignOps leader is similar to that of the CEO with the COO, to the point that we can suggest a title of Chief Design Operations Officer, the CDOO.

    A recent study from McKinsey (2020) has identified a set of tasks pertaining the Chief Design Officer and it provides a clear distinction of duties that CDOs are accountable for and those that they perform. The study divides the CDO’s impact in 3 main transformational areas:

    • the UX
    • the Organisation
    • The Team

    The CDO performs most aspects in the UX area, that include the definition of a portfolio or service strategy, customer segmentation, user identification, project metrics, product experience and product related metrics.

    But when it comes to transform the organisation, and even more so, the team, the CDO is not directly involved in the delivery of those aspects. The McKinsey study does not call out DesignOps as the leader responsible to execute and deliver on those aspects, but the areas that the CDO is accountable for are those performed by the DesignOps Leader.

    When it comes to the team’s transformation, the DesignOps Leader and the Design Leader split responsibilities, with the Design Leader focusing on improving the employee experience and the DesignOps Leader focusing on spreading design best practices across the organisation and representing design.

    But where the DesignOps leader thrives is the teams’ transformation: in this domain the DesignOps leader is directly responsible for all aspects, such as productivity management, budget, prioritisation, utilisation management, Quality assurance, KSA development, team satisfaction.

    These tasks are strategic tasks that the DesignOps lead can carry out through an executive level engagement to ensure all needs and competing values are taken into account to define engagement models and operational roadmaps that maximise investments and satisfaction across the organisation.

    Understanding the right positioning is therefore essential to implement DesignOps at the right altitude and to define the remit and expectations.

  • What is Digital Transformation?

    Everyone is talking about digital transformation: the news are filled with data and stats around massive investments in digital technology and in the need to transform businesses.

    The IDC report 2017 estimates that worldwide spending on digital transformation technologies will grow to more than $2.1 trillion in 2019, while a Forrester study says that 57% of organisations say that implementing key digital technologies is critical to enabling their digital business. Nevertheless a Sloan Review Survey shows that respondents rated “current IT systems” as the third biggest obstacle to achieving digital transformation.

    The relation between digital, IT systems, and digital transformation is still blurred in most cases. Today digital transformation is far too often confused with Digitalization or with Digitization with a strong focus on technologies or platform. In many cases, organisations still believe that digital transformation is achieved by implementing a single platform that could magically transform the whole organisation.

    Unfortunately that is wrong and it’s misleading.

    Because Digital transformation is not about technologies: it’s about transforming the whole organisation through a system thinking approach and it’s about rethinking operational models, business models, processes, and policies, taking people, both employees and customers at the core of the process.

    Because the goal of any digital transformation is to increase value creation for the business through digitally enhanced processes that increase internal efficiency and overall customer and employee satisfaction.

    Digital transformation is en emergent need in today’s post-industrial society: we moved fast from an industrial to a post-industrial era, however operational models and management practices haven’t evolved fast enough.
    For this reason, many organisations prefer to think of Digital transformation as the adoption of digital technologies on the top of mainly inefficient and obsolete operational models, rather than facing a true in depth transformation that begins with understanding the current culture, the customers, and the overall business.

    Digital Transformation is about people, it’s about processes, operational models, business models, leadership, customer experience, employee experience.

    There’s much more to digital transformation than technology — it’s about abandoning old industrial business and management models to embrace new ways of thinking and new ways of working to create value through the creation of valuable relationships. These relationships are multifaceted and multidimensional: good inner relationships within the organisation, supported by appropriate operational models and processes enhance the outer relationship with customers.

    To achieve a real transformation, the company’s buy in is key: for this reason, understanding the organisation’s culture, aspirations, and current experience at all levels becomes key to efficiently manage change.

    To manage change effectively, everyone needs to be involved from the early stages and everyone needs to feel they are part of the change.

    For this reason, a model like the Competing Values Framework and the OCAI survey are essential tools to manage and lead change successfully: if everyone’s voice is heard, if everyone feels they are part of the change and are listened to, change will happen with the internal support by everyone.

    These slides, were presented to students from IIM (india) at ESPC London on July 27th 2017 with the goal to provide tomorrow’s digital leaders a broad vision of what is digital transformation by looking at what and the reasons why change is happening in the business world, define Digital transformation and its dimensions through the lenses of an Experience economy and a post-industrial era. The presentation also presents the Competing Value Framework as a key tool to start understanding organsation’s culture and define a digital transformation roadmap and strategy.
    Author mentioned (and inspirers):
    – Daniel Bell (the post-industrial society)
    – Joe Pine (Experience Economy
    – The ClueTrain Manifesto
    – Quinn and Cameron’s Competing design framework
    – Brian Solis
    – Nichola Negroponte

  • The effects of Management Inertia on your Digital transformation

    Investments in digital transformation are growing and according to ICD worldwide spending on digital transformation technologies will grow to more than $2.1 trillion in 2019. Brian Solis in his report on the state of Digital transformation 2016 mentions that one of the top three digital transformation initiatives for 80% of the sample organisations include a Modernized IT infrastructure with increased agility, flexibility, management, and security.

    Neverless, a report by Capgemini highlighted that since 2000, 52% of companies in the Fortune 500 have either gone bankrupt, been acquired or ceased to exist. This is not the symptom of an economical crisis, but the symptom of an organisational system that is not fit for purpose and a management that is unable to cope with change.

    The growth of technology investments is an indicator of the current confusion and the inability to identify the root causes that are shaking organisations. Many companies are buying the latest technology with the hope that it will magically digitally transformthe whole organisation and business. But things are not so simple. The assumption that Digital Transformation is about technology, is a dangerous and erroneous one. Digital Transformation, as I have said here, is much more about changing perspectives and transforming society and organizations through new ways of thinking and doing enhanced by the technological and digital literacy we have achieved. Digital transformation is about applying a holistic and systems-thinking driven approach to access and see the world, people, and relationships under a brand new light.

    Digital transformation is not about adding the latest tool to the organisation’s technological and digital ecosystem. It’s about analyzing how the organization operates at every level, understanding what are the obsolete practices, acknowledging which processes are hindering the organizations (and more importantly) people’s potential, and admitting that we are well beyond the post — post-industrial era.

    Organisations cannot operate efficiently with industrial or post-industrial processes, because the values and our society have changed. Technology revolutionised how we operate, and the evolution from a product to a service and experience based economy deeply changed the rules of the game.

    And in such a transformed society obsolete industrial manufactory organizational models totally show their weaknesses, because those models emerged to support factories to efficiently produce goods, but today we produce services and experiences. The first symptom of this inertia is reflected in structural tensions that often emerge between departments, employees, and customers. This is because producingexperiences and services requires different management approaches than the production of goods, because the most valuable asset for service production, are people, ideas, and collaboration.

    Applying the same manufactory or production oriented metrics to assess and manage organizations and to develop visions and strategies leads to slow and unpractical ways of managing people and projects, ineffective processes, and increased inefficiencies. Nevertheless, many organizations are still implementing industrial manufactory models to their experience and service oriented organisations.

    This management inertia is what causes the confusion about digital transformation practices and the reduction of digital transformation into magic digital tools to be implemented, leaving people’s management, internal processes, and organizations untouched and unchanged. In the worse cases, the new tools that are sold as “the digital transformation magic wound” simply add a layer of complexity to an already inadequate and inefficient management process, combining innovative technologies with a transformational potential with old models and processes.

    But transformation is a process, not a product. Tools can help, but they are part of the solution, not the solution. If we want to “digitally transform” our kitchen, we cannot just swap the old electric oven for a microwave one, without acknowledging that the processes and functionalities of the two ovens are not interchangeable. We need to learn the new processes to cook with the new oven or we’ll be disappointed if we apply the same process to make a roast with the microwave oven.

    Many organisations are considering or engaging in Digital transformation initiatives, and many fail. This is because often the change is expected to be delivered and lead by organisations that still implement the old paradigm and are not familiar with how a digitally transformed organisation looks like. Change, to really happen, should be lead by people who experience and know the new management models. Because these new models exists, are emerging, and are available. Models like sociocracy and holocracy, flat models that prioritize people, skills, and results over production, are emerging and are proving that different ways to manage organisations can exist and thrive, and that in the experience economy, services and experiences require a management approach that values ideas, soft skills, people, and collaboration.

    What does this mean to organization looking for a change and to really transform their organization inner and outer value generating processes?

    It requires knowledge and awareness: before deciding to go for a digital transformation process that really defeats the management inertia, organisation should invest and learn what digital transformation is and focus on learning the organizational models that can deliver the processes and values that better align with their business model.

    And the best digital transformation partner today is that who knows that transformation means change, and has gone through the process first hand.

    After all, would you ask a vegetarian who never ever tried meat, to cook the perfect steak for you? If the expectations are to have a special meal, and to enjoy the dining experience, chances are, a vegetarian by birth chef would not be the first choice.

    But when it comes to management, most companies willing to test and try innovative models still rely on companies who sell digital transformation without having ever even tried the best practices they praise and suggest.

    Digital transformation can never be reduced to a magic technology: there’s no magic technology that can solve deep management issues overnight. Transformation is a process that requires rethinking people, trust, relationships, and what is value for the organization and its future.